Home • PRRES Inc. Journal • Read the Journal

Impacts of leaky homes and leaky building stigma on older homeowners

Author/s: Bev James, Michael Rehm, Kay Saville-Smith

Date Published: 2/01/2017

Published in: Volume 23 - 2017 Issue 1 (pages 15 - 34)

Abstract

This paper employs mixed methods combining in-depth, semi-structured interviews with quantitative data of paired house sales, administrative data and institutional analysis to investigate the impacts of leaky building syndrome and its potential stigmatising effects on older homeowners in New Zealand. Older homeowners are particularly vulnerable to the negative effects of a leaky home. Adverse impacts were identified on the use value and financial value of older people’s homes, retirement planning, physical and mental health, relationships and social connections. Some face an uncertain housing future and their ability to downsize is compromised. Complex and confusing information and processes around dispute resolution and remediation do not support a positive outcome. This exploratory study raises issues for further research, both in relation to older homeowners and ongoing challenges in addressing weathertightness problems due to non-remediation and remediation failure. This paper is the first to report research on older leaky homeowners’ experiences, issues and impacts. The focus is unique in that it covers not only the experience of owning a leaky home, but also the implications of leaky home stigma for older people’s ability to optimise their housing choices.

Download Full Article

Download the Full Article PDF

14445921.2016.1266983.pdf 14445921.2016.1266983.pdf (1MB)

Keywords

Ageing - Downsizing - Housing - Leaky Building Syndrome - New Zealand - Retirement

References

  • Alexander, S. (2011) The process of building remediation, The Leaky Building Crisis Understanding the Issues. Wellington: In , (Ed.), (pp. –)p:277-299. Thomson Reuters. The Leaky Building Crisis Understanding the Issues.
  • Bain, N. (2003) Re-sale of leaky Condos: Did the buyer Know?. Retrieved March 4, 2016, fromCanada Mortgage and Housing Corporation Technical Series 03–108. Re-sale of leaky Condos: Did the buyer Know?. Retrieved from http://www.wpcn.ca/resources/canada/pdfs/29.pdf
  • Barrett, D. (1998) The Renewal of Trust in Residential Construction. Retrieved March 4, 2016, fromCommission of Enquiry into the Quality of Condominium Construction in British Columbia, submitted to the Lieutenant-Governor in Council, Government of British Columbia. The Renewal of Trust in Residential Construction. Retrieved from http://www.qp.gov.bc.ca/condo/
  • Bell, R.Wadwha, S. (2014) National coastal susceptibility: Vulnerable areas and demographics. Hamilton: National Institute of Water and Atmospheric Research Ltd. National coastal susceptibility: Vulnerable areas and demographics.
  • Clement, D. (2015) New Zealand Herald. (, December 7). Retrieved February 15, 2016, fromNew Zealand Herald. Retrieved from http://m.nzherald.co.nz/property/news/article.cfm?c_id=8&objectid=11552327
  • Davey, J. (2007) Home equity release products in New Zealand: Risks and opportunities. Wellington: (Report prepared for the Retirement Commission as part of the 2007 Review of Retirement Income Policies)New Zealand Institute for Research on Ageing. Home equity release products in New Zealand: Risks and opportunities.
  • Denzin, N.Lincoln, Y. (2000) Sage Handbook of Qualitative Research. Sage. Sage Handbook of Qualitative Research.
  • Douwes, J.Howden-Chapman, P. (2011) An overview of possible health risks from exposure to “leaky buildings”, The leaky building crisis understanding the issues. Wellington: p:71-84. Thomson Reuters. The leaky building crisis understanding the issues.
  • Dupuis, A.Thorns, D. (2011) Living with risk, living in risk: A sociological perspective on New Zealand’s leaky building syndrome, The leaky building crisis understanding the issues. Wellington: p:85-99. Thomson Reuters. The leaky building crisis understanding the issues.
  • Eagleson, B. (2015) Body corporate disclosure regime – summary and practical tips for buyers,. Retrieved February 15, 2016, fromRetrieved from http://www.hobec.co.nz/news-resources/content/posts/property/unit-titles-act-2010-disclosure-regime.aspx
  • Easton, B. (2011) Regulation and leaky buildings, The leaky building crisis understanding the issues. Wellington: In (Ed.), (pp. –)p:35-44. Thomson Reuters. The leaky building crisis understanding the issues.
  • HOBANZ. (2014) Guide to: Leaky buildings. Retrieved March 4, 2016, fromGuide to: Leaky buildings. Retrieved from https://hobanz.org.nz/sites/default/files/attachments/Guide%20to%20Leaky%20Buildings%20Jan,%202016.pdf
  • CRESA, B. (2015) Retirement villages act 2003 monitoring project: Disputes process report 1: International comparison of disputes processes and collation of best practice resources. Wellington: Retrieved March 4, 2016, fromCommission for Financial Capability. Retirement villages act 2003 monitoring project: Disputes process report 1: International comparison of disputes processes and collation of best practice resources. Retrieved from http://www.cffc.org.nz/assets/Uploads/Report-1-RV-disputes.pdf
  • James, B.Saville-SmithK. (2014) “We had our retirement all worked out and then …” learning from older people’s flood experiences. (2014) Report for the Community Resilience and Good Ageing research programme. “We had our retirement all worked out and then …” learning from older people’s flood experiences. Retrieved from www.resilience.goodhomes.co.nz
  • Judd, B.Bridge, C.Davy, L.Adams, T.Liu, E. (2012) Downsizing amongst older Australians. Melbourne: (2012) AHURI Positioning Paper No. 150. Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute. Downsizing amongst older Australians.
  • Kearn, K. (n.d.) Current issues with unit titles. Retrieved February 15, 2016, fromCurrent issues with unit titles. Retrieved from http://www.martellimckegg.co.nz/media/57769/unit%20titles%20act%20seminar%20paper.pdf
  • Koopman-Boyden, P.van der Plas, S.Cameron, M. (2007) Wellbeing – social connectedness and economic standard of living among 65–84 year olds in New Zealand. Wellington: (2007) EWAS Working Paper 9. Family Centre Social Policy Research Unit, and Population Studies Centre, The University of Waikato, Hamilton. Wellbeing – social connectedness and economic standard of living among 65–84 year olds in New Zealand.
  • Layton, B. (2011) Regulating the building industry: A case of regulatory failure, Learning from the past, adapting for the future: Regulatory reform in New Zealand. Auckland: In (Ed.),LexisNexis NZ. Learning from the past, adapting for the future: Regulatory reform in New Zealand.
  • Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment. (2013) Evaluation of the financial assistance package. Wellington:Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment. Evaluation of the financial assistance package.
  • New Zealand Productivity Commission. (2012) Housing affordability inquiry. Wellington:New Zealand Productivity Commission. Housing affordability inquiry.
  • HolbornM.HaralambosM. (2004) Triangulation in social research: Qualitative and quantitative methods can really be mixed, Developments in sociology. Ormskirk: Causeway Press. Developments in sociology.
  • Overview Group. (2002) Report of the overview group on the weathertightness of buildings to the building industry authority. Retrieved March 4, 2016, fromReport of the overview group on the weathertightness of buildings to the building industry authority. Retrieved from http://www.building.govt.nz/UserFiles/File/Weathertightness/Reports/pdf/bia-report-17-9-02.pdf
  • Parliamentary Library. (2002) Leaky buildings. Retrieved March 4, 2016, fromBackground Note. Leaky buildings. Retrieved from http://www.parliament.nz/resource/en-nz/00PLEcoRP02111/1d898e0545fca3fc7da8acf019fad63f32421d4d
  • Patton, M. (2002) Qualitative research and evaluation methods. Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage. Qualitative research and evaluation methods.
  • Penner, D. (2014) Leaky condo crisis rears its head again in B.C., The Vancouver Sun. (, May 22).The Vancouver Sun.
  • Perry, B. (2010) The material wellbeing of older New Zealanders: Background paper for the Retirement Commissioner’s 2010 review. Wellington:Ministry of Social Development. The material wellbeing of older New Zealanders: Background paper for the Retirement Commissioner’s 2010 review.
  • Petersen, M.Parsell, C.Phillips, R.White, G. (2014) Preventing first time homelessness among older Australians. Melbourne: AHURI Final Report No. 222. Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute. Preventing first time homelessness among older Australians.
  • PriceWaterhouseCoopers. (2009) Weathertightness – Estimating the Cost. Wellington: Retrieved March 4, 2016, fromReport prepared for Department of Building and Housing. Weathertightness – Estimating the Cost. Retrieved from http://www.building.govt.nz/userfiles/file/news/whrs/pdf/pwc-weathertightness-estimating-cost-full-report.pdf
  • Productivity Commission. (2015) Housing decisions of older Australians. Canberra:Commission Research Paper. Productivity Commission. Housing decisions of older Australians.
  • Rehm, M. (2009) Judging a house by its cover: Leaky building stigma and house prices in New Zealand, International Journal of Housing Markets and Analysis. 2, –.p:57-77. International Journal of Housing Markets and Analysis.
  • Rothbauer, P. (2008) Triangulation, The sage encyclopedia of qualitative research methods. Thousand Oaks, CA: In (Ed.), (pp. –)p:892-894. Sage. The sage encyclopedia of qualitative research methods.
  • Saville-Smith, K. (2013) Housing assets: A paper for the 2013 review of retirement income. (.). Retrieved March 4, 2016, fromPrepared for the Commission for Financial Literacy and Retirement Income. Housing assets: A paper for the 2013 review of retirement income. Retrieved from http://www.cffc.org.nz/assets/Documents/RI-Review-2013-Housing-Assets-and-Retirement-Income.pdf
  • Statistics New Zealand. (2015) 2013 Census QuickStats about people aged 65 and over. Retrieved March 4, 2016, from2013 Census QuickStats about people aged 65 and over. Retrieved from www.stats.govt.nz
  • Statistics New Zealand. (2016) Building consents issued. Retrieved March 4, 2016, fromBuilding consents issued. Retrieved from http://www.stats.govt.nz/browse_for_stats/industry_sectors/Construction/building-consents-issued-info-releases.aspx
  • Stewart, P. (2014) A lingering legacy, Build. 144, –.p:74-76. Build.
  • The Treasury. (2015) Aide memoire: Weathertight appropriations in vote housing. Retrieved March 4, 2016, fromAide memoire: Weathertight appropriations in vote housing. Retrieved from http://www.treasury.govt.nz/downloads/pdfs/b15-info/b15-3144738.pdf
  • Wood, G.Smith, S.Ong, R.Cigdem, M. (2013) The edges of home ownership. Melbourne: AHURI Final Report No. 216. Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute. The edges of home ownership.